Oscar Nominations Lack Surprises: A Closer Look at Bradley Cooper’s ‘Is This Thing On?’

Oscar Nominations Reflect Predictability

This week’s Oscar nominations left little to the imagination, as the landscape appeared largely predictable to film critics and enthusiasts alike. While Kate Hudson’s nod for Best Actress in the charming film “Song Sung Blue” raised a few eyebrows, most of the nominees were anticipated weeks in advance. Notably, “Wicked: For Good” faced disappointment, failing to secure spots in several significant categories.

Among the films that were overlooked, director Bradley Cooper’s “Is This Thing On?” stood out, not for its acclaim but for its complete absence from the awards conversation. This absence is particularly disheartening, considering the film’s compelling narrative and strong performances. Cooper’s third directorial venture dives into the complexities of marriage and divorce, presenting a fresh perspective on the trials of middle age.

A Glimpse into ‘Is This Thing On?’

Starring Will Arnett as a man grappling with the impending dissolution of his marriage, the film unfolds in an unexpected setting: an open mic night at a New York City comedy club. This environment becomes a makeshift therapy session, allowing Arnett’s character to channel his frustrations and emotions through humor and candid rants. The performance is a standout, with Arnett delivering a remarkably nuanced portrayal that showcases his range beyond the comedic roles he’s best known for.

Cooper also stars in the film as a struggling actor, a role that, while adding some comedic relief, feels somewhat disconnected from the central marital drama. Laura Dern plays the potential ex-wife, offering a captivating performance that further enriches the film. Her character finds herself torn between her failing marriage and an unexpected attraction to a long-lost friend, played by none other than Peyton Manning. This unusual twist adds an extra layer of intrigue to the narrative.

Audience Reception and Critical Acclaim

Despite its lack of awards recognition, “Is This Thing On?” has resonated with audiences, boasting an impressive 86 percent “fresh” rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Reviewers have praised the film for its insightful commentary on relationships and the struggles of middle age. However, it seems that even with solid critical feedback, the film struggled to gain traction during its theatrical run. Many potential viewers may not have even been aware of its existence, which could explain its absence from the awards conversation.

In the competitive landscape of awards season, the consensus is a significant factor. As critical praise builds in the fall months, certain films are propelled into the spotlight while others, regardless of merit, fade into the background. For instance, “After the Fall,” a bold critique of today’s Cancel Culture, showcased a mesmerizing performance by Julia Roberts yet failed to gain the recognition it deserved.

In a similar vein, “Is This Thing On?” deserves a viewing, if only for Arnett’s transformative performance and the refreshingly honest portrayal of middle-aged characters. It treats these individuals not as caricatures but as relatable souls navigating the complexities of love, life, and identity.